Rule DD0094 issue

DD0094 issue: def:CommentOID attribute

Not a bad idea to download and read the "ARM" specification (it is at: https://www.cdisc.org/system/files/members/standard/foundational/adam/ARM-for-Define-XML.zip).

The only element in your snippet (at least for the arm:* elements) where def:CommentOID can occur is on the <arm:AnalysisDatasets> element.
From the specification (read it!), page 26: "Usage: Conditional: Required if there is more than one analysis dataset needed to create the respective result" and "Description: Reference to the unique ID of a def:CommentDef element that contains the comment."

So you will need to have something like:
<arm:AnalysisDatasets def:CommentOID="COM.1">
<arm:AnalysisDataset ItemGroupOID="IG.ADEEG">
<def:WhereClauseRef WhereClauseOID="WC.T_8_2_1.ADEEG.R1"/>
<arm:AnalysisVariable ItemOID="IT.ADEEG.AVAL"/>
<arm:AnalysisVariable ItemOID="IT.ADEEG.CHG"/>
</arm:AnalysisDataset>
<arm:AnalysisDataset ItemGroupOID="IG.ADSL">
<def:WhereClauseRef WhereClauseOID="WC.T_8_2_1.ADSL.R2"/>
</arm:AnalysisDataset>
</arm:AnalysisDatasets>

and then of course have the comment itself, something like:
<def:CommentDef OID="COM.1">
<Description><TranslatedText xml:lang="en">..........</TranslatedText></Description>
</def:CommentDef>

Thank you, Jozef.

Thank you, Jozef.

Sergiy

on July 19, 2019

P21

See example in CDISC ARM v1.0 standard specifications on page 14

Hi Oleksii, 

There is an example in CDISC ARM v1.0 standard specification document on page 14. There is also an example in sample define.xml included into CDISC ARM v1.0 standard package.

Note, that another example code on page 16 violates DD0094 rule.

Kind Regards, 

Sergiy

P.S. DD0094 rule is specified on page 26: "Def:CommentOID ... Required if there is more than one analysis dataset needed to create the respective result"

DD0094 issue: def:CommentOID attribute

As well Sergiy as the ARM-specification have a small typo on page 26:
it must be "def:CommentOID" instead of "Def:CommentOID". XML is case sensitive.

Lex

on July 21, 2019

DD0094 issue: defCommentOID attribute

Some clarification about the examples in the ARM specification. The examples in section 4 are not complete XML fragments with all required elements and attributes. Each fragment has a focus on a particular element. For example, the code that Sergiy mentions from page 16 is about the selection criteria (WhereClauseOID and def:WhereClauseDef). That is why it does not include arm:AnalysisDatasets/def:CommentOID and also not def:CommentDef. 

It would not make sense to apply all validation rules to every code fragment.