Blog

Pinnacle 21 is pleased to announce that we’ve been awarded a renewed contract to provide software and services in ongoing support of the FDA’s DataFit program.

According to the FDA’s Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER), which made the decision:

Pinnacle 21 is honored to announce that our president and CEO, Max Kanevsky, has been named to the PharmaVOICE 100 Class of 2015.

The PharmaVOICE 100 is an annual list that recognizes the year’s most inspiring people in the life-sciences industry — leaders who have made a significant impact on their peers, their colleagues, their companies and their communities, as well as the industry at large.

When CDISC published Version 1.3 of its ADaM Validation Rules, a lot of you wondered what to make of it.

According to CDISC: “Some checks have been reworded for clarification … [and] 75 new checks have been added to cover rules not previously addressed. [These] additional checks cover the addition of checks for Adverse Events (ADAE) and the ADaM Basic Data Structure for Time-to-Event Analyses (BDS-TTE).”

To paint a clear picture of what all this means, and how the industry should respond, Pinnacle 21 hosted a recent webinar on this topic. The webinar — titled, “ADaM Validation Update from OpenCDISC” — provided an overview of these changes, and shared our experience of the most common issues in ADaM submission data observed across the industry.

The 2015 PharmaSUG Annual Conference, in Orlando, Florida, was an important and telling event. Pinnacle 21 was there, as both a presenter and exhibitor. The event drew more than 600 attendees, who generated a wealth of intriguing questions and discussions over the four-day stretch.

If you attended our programs, or witnessed the buzz of activity around the booths, then you saw what we saw: pharmaceutical software users who were eager to learn more about how to navigate FDA regulatory submissions in the months and years to come.

Pinnacle 21 ran two important programs to try to answer some of our attendees’ biggest concerns:

On March 24, 2015, CDISC published Version 1.3 of its ADaM Validation Rules. The release's main goal was to add new business rules for ADAE (Adverse Events) and BDS-TTE (Time-to-Event Analysis), and, at the same time, clean up some of the checks from the prior release.

But these new rules still don’t provide a complete solution. ADaM validation requires the ability to supplement the ADaM rules with sponsor-specific controlled terminology and value level checks ... and the ability to test those checks with the same software used by the FDA.

Through this webinar, we’ll provide an overview of recent changes and share our experience of the most common issues in ADaM submission data observed across the industry. Our speaker will be Pinnacle 21’s Michael DiGiantomasso. Mike serves on the CDISC’s ADaM Validation sub-team and is a Data Fitness Analyst on the FDA JumpStart project.

For your convenience, we’ll be providing this webinar at two different times.

In this webinar, we will cover:

• Review of all ADaM validation rules and categories
• Overview of datasets recognized by OpenCDISC
• Adding sponsor-specific CT and VLM checks
• Common ADaM issues in submission data
• Rules for the upcoming release of ADaM IG v1.1

Best regards.
OpenCDISC Team

The next meeting of the NJ CDISC Users Group will be held the afternoon of June 17, 2015 at Medidata in NYC.
 
If you are interested in presenting at the meeting, please contact Patricia Majcher by Friday, May 22, 2015.  Presentations should be no more than 20 minutes long (excluding time for Q&A).  Any CDISC-related topic is welcome.  We look forward to hearing from you!
 
Here is the link for online registration; registration closes Friday, June 5:  https://www.survey-expert.com/web/surveyIndex.asp?U=0001005008105033328
Please note that teleconferencing will not be available for this meeting.
 
The final agenda will be posted about 1-2 weeks prior to the meeting, and instructions for attending the meeting will be emailed to registered attendees about 1 week prior to the meeting.

In the Beginning

It was late 2007. Mad Men was the hottest show on TV. The BlackBerry was still the most popular smartphone. Senator Barack Obama was securing his party’s nomination for the next presidential election. And a young clinical data exchange specialist named Max Kanevsky was contemplating the future of the biopharmaceutical industry.

During his tenure at Merck, Max had been responsible for integrating the company with many external partners (e.g., laboratories, CROs, joint ventures, technology providers), working with many non-standardized sources of data. Though the norm, gathering all that disparate data and mapping it into Merck’s internal standard was a huge challenge. When the Clinical Data Interchange Standards Consortium (CDISC) started to make headway in its mission to develop a global set of standards, it marked a new beginning. CDISC would eventually define the standards for the entire industry.

But Max wondered how sponsors would possibly manage such a sea-change. At the time, software options to help ensure a submission’s compliance with FDA business rules were limited. WebSDM offered limited performance and capabilities, at a price point that was prohibitive to many. Meanwhile, Max was helping Merck with its early manual implementations of CDISC standards, including LAB, ODM and SDTM, which were difficult and time consuming. And each new challenge provided an obstacle that could threaten FDA approval of any given drug. There had to be a better way. But what?

On March 24, 2015, CDISC published Version 1.3 of its ADaM Validation Rules.

So, what’s changed?

In the simplest terms: the release’s biggest enhancement is the ability to recognize and validate ADAE (Adverse Event Analysis) and BDS-TTE (Time-to-Event Analysis) datasets. CDISC has added 75 new rules in total, and, at the same time, cleaned up some of the checks from the prior release to ensure that their failure criteria is machine-testable.

So, what should concern you?

These published business rules conform to the definition of CDISC’s intention that each rule requirement be broken down into its constituent parts and should be machine-testable. For example, a simple rule which states “C BETWEEN A and B” will be stated as C >= A and C<=B. This normalized model works for business requirement capture … but it can make implementation, testing and human understanding more complicated than they need to be.

Beyond that, these newly enhanced ADaM validation rules still don’t provide a complete solution. Since ADaM IG v1.0, CDISC has been providing mere specifications documents. ADaM validation requires more than that. You need the ability to supplement the ADaM rules with sponsor-specific checks, especially for sponsor defined controlled terminology and value level metadata. And you need to be able to test those checks with the same software used by the FDA.

It was a long time coming. But, finally, on December 17, 2014, the FDA announced that applications must be submitted electronically, and that submissions will be required to contain study data in conformance with CDISC standards.

The industry has been given 24 months from the publication of the final guidance documents to comply. Not wanting to waste any precious time, Pinnacle 21 hosted two webinars — on January 7th and 8th, 2015 — to help guide you through the new processes.

Registration is now open for the next NJ CDISC User Group meeting, scheduled for Wednesday, January 28, 2015 from 1-5pm. The meeting will be held at TAKE Solutions in Princeton, NJ. Please register by January 20, via the link below:

Register for the NJ CDISC User Group

Meeting Agenda:

• Kevin Lee (Accenture):  Standards Metadata Management: Version Control and its Governance
• Fred Hofstetter and Ian Fleming (d-Wise):  Leveraging R and Shiny for point and click ADaM Analysis
• Archana Bhaskaran and Kannan Subramanian (Novartis):  Metadata Management – Our Journey Thus Far
• Sangeeta Bhattacharya:  Trial Design Domains
• Max Kanevsky and Sergiy Sirichenko (Pinnacle 21):  FDA Finalizes Requirements for Standardized Data
• Andrew Ndikom (Novartis Vaccines):  ADaM Compliant Table Creation Macros